Post Content

As an energy conscious car-buyer, do you pay attention to the MPG (miles-per-gallon) rating of the vehicle? Once you decide on the price range, style of the car, how many seats, legroom, or baggage space, is mileage – a measure of energy efficiency – a factor that tips you from one vehicle to another?

Until recently, there was no way to easily figure energy efficiency into a home buying decision. Decisions boiled down to neighborhood, price, style, number of rooms, overall space and the like. If you were vacillating between two similar properties, you could ask to see last years’ energy bills. But energy expenditures for identical homes could swing wildly between a young family with a TV always on and an air conditioner blasting, and a retired couple who travels a lot. Their energy bills might not tell you anything about the home itself: the energy characteristics of the structure and its systems, like heating and cooling.

energy performance scorecardEnter HomeMPG, a Massachusetts energy-saving initiative. The Department of Energy Resources (DOER) received a $2.6 million grant from the U.S. Department of Energy to pilot an energy performance score (EPS) in residential homes. An EPS is an “asset” rating that’s analogous to a car’s MPG rating. Behavior is taken out of the equation so that any home’s energy use can be compared to any other home, allowing for an apples-to-apples comparison. It’s distinct from meter data that relates to the energy-using behavior or the occupants. The HomeMPG rating, as seen on this scorecard, is a two or three digit number equal to the million British Thermal Units (MMBtus) a house uses in one year.

Homeowners in the pilot area received an initial scorecard during their no-cost Mass Save® home energy assessment and a second scorecard after they completed energy efficiency upgrades. The initiative was piloted from April 2012 through March 2014 in eight municipalities in the western part of the state. Home MPG added “extras” to Mass Save’s standard home energy assessment to show increased energy savings in homes that completed efficiency work. Homes heated with fuel oil yielded Home MPG’s deepest penetration. Adding to the standard Mass Save program, HomeMPG aimed to promote ‘more’ and ‘deeper’ retrofits by including the following extras:home mpg logo

  • Energy Performance Scorecard (EPS) before and after efficiency improvements to offer new types of information to homeowners, including annual MMBtu use, a home’s carbon footprint and the financial impact of energy efficiency work
  • Thermal imaging analysis that visually depicts areas of needed energy efficiency improvement
  • Local outreach and marketing to educate community members
  • Bonus insulation incentives and equipment rebates
  • Technical assistance service for customers considering equipment upgrades, to answer questions regarding fuel switching and installing new technologies
  • Real estate broker and appraiser training to make the link between the EPS, the market for high energy performance homes, and the real estate community

The level of participation – both assessments and resulting energy saving upgrades – enabled analyses that were informative to Mass Save program administrators, DOER and DOE.

  • 3866 initial scorecards were issued via energy assessments
  • 1500+ updated scorecards were delivered to participants that completed efficiency work
  • 42% of participants completed work to date
  • Penetration rate was measured at ~6-8%
  • 1252 homes completed multiple measures (e.g. air sealing, insulation, and/or HVAC equipment)

Based on a consultant’s telephone survey of 69 Home MPG participants, 98% of homeowners stated that the scorecard was either “very” or “somewhat” useful in making efficiency-improvement decisions. All of the homeowners who recalled receiving a scorecard (84%) said that the scorecard was very or somewhat easy to understand. Assessment of the outcomes of the Home MPG initiative continues, and stakeholders are evaluating the lessons learned.

Written By:


Energy Efficiency Analyst

As an Energy Efficiency Analyst for DOER, Ben Pignatelli manages implementation of a grant to incorporate energy performance scores into the Mass Save® home energy efficiency program, Home MPG. Ben also serves as chair of Boston Inner City Outings, a program of the Sierra Club that takes inner city kids on outdoor trips. Before joining DOER, he rebuilt Sierra Pizza in South Lake Tahoe, CA. A graduate of the University of New Hampshire, with an MBA from BU, Ben is often seen in biking gear, his favored mode of commuting.

Recent Posts

Leading By Example Earns EPA Award posted on Jun 16

Leading By Example Earns EPA Award

This spring, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s New England Office chose this historic hall to recognize bold action and innovation of a different kind. It recognized Massachusetts state government’s Leading by Example (LBE) program during a 2015 Earth Day event at Faneuil Hall, awarding LBE a 2015 Environmental Merit Award in the governmental category.

“L-E-D”ing by Example – Illuminating Energy Efficiency on Earth Day posted on May 4

“L-E-D”ing by Example – Illuminating Energy Efficiency on Earth Day

On what was a beautifully sunny Earth Day, a crowd gathered at Lynn Heritage State Park to watch local electrical contractor, Coviello Electric, install a shoebox LED lighting fixture, the last of 30 at the site to make the transition to LEDs. The conversion took just five minutes and, once complete, the crowd cheered as the new LED light was switched on for the first time – a symbolic act that highlighted the two phased Department of Conservation and Recreation project to retrofit approximately 4,500 outdoor lighting fixtures.

HVAC Challenges? How Arlington Gets Answers posted on Apr 22

HVAC Challenges? How Arlington Gets Answers

I wanted to understand, day or night, on site or off, if my heating and cooling systems were operating efficiently. While not at the same scale as software giant, Microsoft, Arlington is utilizing the same fault detection and diagnostics software program, to analyze operations and upgrade HVAC efficiency.