Post Content

wordsoflaw-300x100

 

Words of law is a regular feature of Massachusetts Law Updates, highlighting a particular word or phrase and its meaning in law.

Today’s phrase is search warrant.

search warrant, n. (18c) Criminal law. A judge’s written order authorizing a law-enforcement officer to conduct a search of a specified place and to seize evidence. See Fed. R. Crim. P. 41.

 –  Black’s Law Dictionary, 10th ed., Bryan A. Garner, Editor in Chief, Thomson Reuters, 2014.

Massachusetts law addresses the issuance of a search warrant for documentary evidence in the possession of an attorney.

M.G.L. c. 276, § 1, forbids issuance of a search warrant for documentary evidence in the possession of a lawyer, psychotherapist, or clergyman who is reasonably believed to maintain a privileged relationship with a criminal suspect unless there is probable cause to believe that the evidence will be otherwise destroyed, concealed, or lost . . . Evidence entrusted to a lawyer that is not itself privileged (or contains privileged information), and for which there is probable cause to believe constitutes evidence of a crime under investigation, is not beyond the reach of an anticipatory warrant issued pursuant to M.G.L. c. 276, § 1Commonwealth v. Hernandez,   475 Mass. 267, 277 (2016) (defendant’s cell phone containing messages linking him to the shooting of a witness). See also Matter of a Grand Jury Investigation470 Mass. 399, 420 (2015) (concurring opinion suggesting a protocol for the seizure by way of a search warrant of unprivileged evidence held by an attorney on behalf of a client). Compare In re Search Warrant, 521 A.2d 422, 428 (Pa. 1987) (“There are no privileged isles beyond the reaches of a properly predicated search warrant”). The statute does not restrict searches of lawyers who are themselves targets of criminal investigation. Cf. In re Impounded Case (Law Firm), 840 F.2d 196, 200 (3d Cir. 1988) (searches of law offices are not per se unreasonable); United States v. Mittelman, 999 F.2d 440, 445 (9th Cir. 1993) (same). ”

“Searches with Warrants: Third Party Searches”, Richard G. Stearns, Massachusetts Criminal Law: A Prosecutors Guide, Online Edition, 2018.

In Federal cases, United States Attorneys also exercise close control over searches of premises of attorneys in order to balance respect for attorney-client relationships with the need for law enforcement to gather evidence of a crime. Their procedure for “Searches of Premises of Subject Attorneys” is detailed in the U.S. Attorney’s Manual.

Written By:

Recent Posts

Index to blog post series about standing posted on Oct 22

In order to help navigating in and around our series about standing that was posted during the last two weeks, the following index may help: Words(s) of the month – standing posted October 16, 2019, from Black’s Law Dictionary, 11th ed., Bryan A. Garner, Editor   …Continue Reading Index to blog post series about standing

Do Ecosystems Have Standing?  posted on Oct 21

  Ecosystems, such as lakes, valleys, and forests, are treated by the courts, for the most part, in the same way that animals or species are, when it comes to legal standing to sue. (See our recent posts: Do Animals Have Standing? parts 1 & 2)    …Continue Reading Do Ecosystems Have Standing? 

Do Animals Have Standing to Sue? Part 2: Animals filing as individuals posted on Oct 20

Do Animals Have Standing to Sue?  Part 2: Animals filing as individuals

  A dolphin walked up to the bar in Massachusetts, but was told it had no standing. Well, at least legally. A male dolphin named Kama was named as a plaintiff in a case in the United States District Court for the District of Massachusetts   …Continue Reading Do Animals Have Standing to Sue? Part 2: Animals filing as individuals