Post Content

 

 

shutterstock_317119784Most landlord and tenant relationships are professional, if not amicable, and without incident. But when there is a problem, how should it be resolved? There are various remedies that can address a host of problems between landlords and tenants. Find some below.

  • Communication: Often overlooked, the first and best solution is for the landlord and tenant to schedule a time to discuss the issue in an effort to quickly resolve it.
  • Withhold Rent: If the landlord refuses to fix a condition, one option available to the tenant is to withhold all or some of the rent until the landlord makes repairs. Landlords are obligated to provide safe and habitable housing under the state sanitary code promulgated by the Massachusetts Department of Public Health and the warranty of habitability, and so the tenant’s obligation to pay the full amount may be suspended until repairs are made. Another alternative is for the tenant to make repairs and then deduct the costs from the rent. However, tenants should be careful to consider the questions below as to whether their situation meets the requirements for withholding rent, including:
  1. Does the condition exist in the apartment and not the common areas?
  2. Does the condition “endanger or materially impair” the health, safety, or well-being of anyone living there?
  3. Does the landlord know about the condition?
  4. Was the condition caused by someone or something outside of the tenant’s control?
  5. Can the landlord make repairs without requiring the tenant to move out temporarily or permanently?

If the answer is yes to all of these questions, it is possible that a tenant may legally be able to withhold rent. It is very important that a tenant keep diligent records of correspondence with the landlord in case the situation escalates to legal action. Additionally, tenants should consult an attorney about the proper procedures, advisability and consequences of withholding rent. To that end, Housing Courts often have lawyers on hand to answer these questions. The housing court utilizes a more formalized legal proceeding over civil and criminal actions, including resolution of issues of health/safety, personal injury, breach of contract, discrimination, property damage and other claims.

  • Mediation: If relations between the landlord and tenant are too strained another option is to seek a neutral third-party mediator. For more information on mediation services, contact your Local Consumer Program or other mediation service.
  • 30 Day Demand Letter: If an informal mediation is unsuccessful, the next step may be to submit a Demand Letter 30 days before filing a claim in court. The letter must outline the complaint, list the harm suffered, and explain how the tenant wishes to have the problem resolved. More information on 30 Day Demand Letters and a template are available online on our website.
  • Small Claims Court: Small claims court is a less formal (and generally less expensive) court proceeding designed to settle disputes of $7,000 or less, generally without the aid of an attorney.

Written By:

Recent Posts

HIC—Easy as 1-2-3! Part 3: Guaranty Fund posted on Sep 13

HIC—Easy as 1-2-3!  Part 3: Guaranty Fund

In parts one and two of our “HIC-Easy as 1-2-3!” blog series you learned about the Home Improvement Contractor (HIC) law and how to apply for the Arbitration program. Now we’ll cover the fund that may reimburse a homeowner with an unpaid final judgment against   …Continue Reading HIC—Easy as 1-2-3! Part 3: Guaranty Fund

HIC—Easy as 1-2-3! Part 2: Arbitration posted on Sep 9

HIC—Easy as 1-2-3!  Part 2: Arbitration

After the ink is dry on your home improvement contract and the job is underway, sometimes things don’t go as planned. Thankfully, the Home Improvement Contractor (HIC) law Arbitration program allows homeowners and registered contractors the opportunity to seek a resolution should a dispute arise.   …Continue Reading HIC—Easy as 1-2-3! Part 2: Arbitration

HIC— Easy as 1-2-3! Introduction posted on Aug 30

HIC— Easy as 1-2-3! Introduction

If you are a home improvement contractor or homeowner in Massachusetts, we’ve got you covered with our introductory guide to understanding the Home Improvement Contractor (HIC) programs – from both perspectives, the homeowner’s and contractor’s. This introduction to HIC programs is the first of our   …Continue Reading HIC— Easy as 1-2-3! Introduction