Post Content

A plaintiff who requested an abuse prevention order was entitled to a prompt evidentiary hearing under G.L.c. 209A despite the fact that the defendant was facing possible consequences in his criminal proceedings if he were to testify in the Chapter 209A proceeding.

“Barring an agreement of the parties or emergency circumstances, both sides are entitled to an evidentiary hearing within ten days,” Chief Justice Roderick L. Ireland wrote for a unanimous court.

“Notwithstanding that [defendant Scott] Capuano faced a potentially difficult choice between testifying in the c. 209A case or asserting his privilege against self-incrimination, [plaintiff Aneeta] Singh was nevertheless entitled to a prompt evidentiary hearing on her claim under c. 209A,” Ireland added. “While the decision whether to draw an adverse inference based on Capuano’s failure to testify was ultimately one for the judge as fact finder, the judge was obliged to consider whether such an inference was fair and reasonable based on all the circumstances and evidence before him.”

The case is Singh vs. Capuano (and a consolidated case), 468 Mass. 328, decided June 11, 2014.

See also our webpages: Massachusetts Law About Domestic Violence and Massachusetts Law about Defending Against a c.209A Order.

Tags: ,

Recent Posts

Criminal solicitation as a crime posted on Mar 27

Black’s Law Dictionary (10th edition, 2014), defines “criminal solicitation”, under “solicitation” (2), as:   “The criminal offense of urging, advising, commanding, or otherwise inciting another to commit a crime <convicted of solicitation of murder>.   Solicitation is an inchoate offense distinct from the solicited crime.  Under the   …Continue Reading Criminal solicitation as a crime

Massachusetts Declaration of Rights – Selected Secondary Sources posted on Feb 2

Massachusetts Declaration of Rights - Selected Secondary Sources

Selected Secondary Sources From January 1, 2019 through January 30, 2019, Massachusetts Law Updates presented a daily series of blog posts showcasing the 30 Articles in the Declaration of Rights in the Massachusetts Constitution. In addition to the text of the Articles, the posts include   …Continue Reading Massachusetts Declaration of Rights – Selected Secondary Sources

Massachusetts Declaration of Rights – Acknowledgments posted on Feb 1

Massachusetts Declaration of Rights - Acknowledgments

Acknowledgments The series of Massachusetts Law Updates blog posts showcasing the 30 Articles in the Declaration of Rights in the Massachusetts Constitution, posted in January of 2019, would not have been possible had not the articles been drafted by John Adams at his kitchen table   …Continue Reading Massachusetts Declaration of Rights – Acknowledgments